Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | djtriptych's commentslogin

I worked in the IAC NYC HQ for a while (as Dir Engineering for The Daily Beast).

It was really nice walking into that space. Always been influenced by architecture in my engineering career and it was really nice to have that pedigree infused into my workspace just a little bit. It's just a little dose of delight every day.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IAC_Building


I also worked there for quite some time and always enjoyed walking into that building each morning.

The 9th (top) floor cafeteria was such a nice touch and offered great views up and down the Hudson.

I took this photo[0] from up there of Space Shuttle Enterprise being delivered to the Intrepid in 2012.

[0] https://imgur.com/a/XQpXXzE


nice!

I'm pretty sure the engineer at the nuclear plant I visited in elementary school drank a glass of water out of that pool to demonstrate how safe it was.

I hope I'm misremembering that but it's a pretty strong memory that totally locked in for me that that water is not necessarily dangerous.


Serious question, as daft as it might sound - do they have to chlorinate the water to stop stuff growing in it? I'd expect it'd be about "swimming pool" warm so just great for all sorts of manky algae growing.


The water is borated and heavily purified. You don’t want stuff growing inside, but at the same time you don’t want to have chlorinated water slowly corroding the metal components.


Check out this study. Pretty wild! [https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7760952/]


I also read in the XKCD thing that it might be up to about 50° so it's probably a bit uncomfortable for most algae type things.

I bet there's some good chance of getting wacky extremophiles though!


50C is terribly hot for a swim.

Hot spring baths usually top out around 42-43C


Would you mind sharing a link to "the xkcd thing" if you have it?

edit: sorry for being lazy, I scrolled a bit more and found it.



Relevant: "For the kinds of radiation coming off spent nuclear fuel, every 7 centimeters of water cuts the amount of radiation in half."


On the picture, the fuel rods are indeed protected by a huge quantity of water above them. But what happens below them ? They seem to be in direct contact with the ground...


People tend to avoid casually tunneling under nuclear pools.


I would guess that in reality they are either suspended and/or there is enough concrete at the bottom


Chlorinating the water would have adverse effects on material strength and longevity. Even irradiated and heated to 50c, I’ll bet there’s some extremophile bacteria in there somewhere.


Just an update: I finally remembered that it was the UVA research reactor (since decommissioned). https://news.virginia.edu/content/reacting-history

But now 100% sure that actually happened. Also it was likely a professor and not a working engineer drinking the water which makes much more sense.


Had a buddy on a nuclear sub drink water from the primary coolant loop when he joined the team.

While I do see this as a form of hazing which I am morally opposed to-

8oz (.237 liters) of primary coolant in a properly maintained pressurized water reactor might contain up to 13mrem of orally ingestible radiation, or approximately the radiation of a chest x-ray. (For comparison you get between 3-8 milirem on a 7 hour transatlantic flight)

Don’t make it your primary source of hydration and you’ll be ok. If the fuel is degraded or there is a leak (unlikely in properly maintained PWRs) the radiation dose is significantly higher.


That makes zero sense. Radiation is not a component of water; it is literally photons[0]. In the nanosecond after you fill the glass, all the radiation in it has left the volume.

I'd drink it. It's just extremely pure water, with a nuclear flashlight at the bottom of the pool - which no one could see, even if they had gamma-ray glasses on[1], because the water attenuates it so much.

[0] Or ions of hydrogen or helium, in the case of alpha and beta radiation.

[1] Which it turns out were way less cool than the Sea Monkeys(tm).


Radiation isn’t contained in the water as photons, but the coolant itself becomes radioactive through neutron activation. Even with intact fuel rods, oxygen in the water turns into N-16 with a half-life of about seven seconds, and trace metals like nickel and cobalt form isotopes such as Co-58 and Co-60. These emit strong gamma radiation while the reactor operates.

The primary coolant is not simply pure water; it contains boric acid, lithium hydroxide, dissolved hydrogen, and trace corrosion products like iron, nickel, cobalt, and chromium. Under power level neutron flux, some of these elements become short- or medium-lived radionuclides. Once removed from the core, most of the activity decays within minutes, but during operation the water is measurably radioactive.

An eight-ounce sample taken from the loop at power would carry roughly the dose of a chest X-ray before it decayed away, due to these activated isotopes rather than residual photons [EPRI PWR Primary Water Chemistry Guidelines; NUREG-1437][0].

I was on site for the mid cycle outage of three mile island unit 1 around 2005. I did the data sync and transfer for the steam generator inspection, but got tutored by some old PHDs during the down time.

[0] https://downloads.regulations.gov/NRC-2020-0101-0142/content...


Thank you very much! TIL!


I mean, apparently the inventor of lead additive to gasoline used to pour the chemical over his hands to demonstrate how safe it was -- even though he knew it was actually quite toxic. So there are people who will knowingly give themselves small doses of poison to keep the money flowing.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IV3dnLzthDA&t=604s


Fair enough - although this engineer didn't stand much to gain by impressing a bunch of 10 year olds.


Loved it too. Made me want to write a schema for other developers to add (tool, frequency_of_use, category, description) tuples.


Same. I have an M1 Max Studio and it's just laughing at the little workloads I throw at it (pro photo editing, music production, software dev, generally all at the same time).

It just never sweats AT ALL - it feels like a decade from obsolescence based on what I'm doing now.

It would have to be an order of magnitude faster for me to even notice at this point.


Obsolescence for Macs comes when Apple decides not to allow your mac update the OS to the latest one.


Hasn’t happened in a long time and people seem to use a utility open core to install newer or the latest macos on old Macs.

https://dortania.github.io/OpenCore-Legacy-Patcher/


That's Intel-only, and will be of increasingly little use when Apple stops releasing Intel builds of new releases of macOS.


Fair point, but it covers all the intel laptops which has some value.

Hopefully there will be some insight from what Asahi Linux is doing or has in store and what might be transferrable.


then you turn it into a hackintosh or install linux on the machine instead (Asahi Linux is looking pretty good for silicon)


> Obsolescence for Macs comes when Apple decides not to allow your mac update the OS to the latest one.

That doesn’t make it obsolete, at all.


When they stop releasing security patches for that OS version 2 years later, it becomes more risky to connect the thing to a network. Or take in any data from the outside, really, whether it's via Bluetooth, or USB drive.

And then there's 3rd party software that will stop supporting that old OS version, in part because Apple's dev tools make that difficult.

Eventually, Apple's own services will stop supporting that OS - no convenient iCloud support.

Finally, the root CA certs bundled with the OS will become too out of date to use.

I'm planning on putting Linux on my Intel Mac Mini soon. But when a M3+ Mini goes out of support, will we have that option?


Even my 2017 MBP on macOS 13 still gets security updates. Heck iPhone 6 got a security update recently.

Your points are valid but it’s not 2 years, it’s more than that for big vulnerabilities.


> Even my 2017 MBP on macOS 13 still gets security updates.

Has it had one since macOS 26 came out? They usually do 2 versions behind - in the summer, that was macOS 13, but now it's macOS 14.


macOS 13 stopped getting any updates on September 15. Insert coin to continue.

https://endoflife.date/macos


Don't forget about Bootcamp for the (soon) obsolete Intels .

With a debloated Windows 10 (which we're not going to connect to the internet anyway) they can live on for older games.


I’ve got a 2010 MBP that’s still perfectly suitable, but without OS updates, I can’t get a browser that websites will load cleanly on, can’t use Xcode, bunch of the Apple services the company hooks you on don’t work, etc. Used OpenCore bootloader to extend its life into newer macOSes, but that’s getting hard to keep up with. What a (e)waste.


You can use Ubuntu. I use Ubuntu on a 2009 MBP and on a 2010 too.


Hadn't thought of doing that - I'm not a natural Linux person myself and I'm repurposing it for an 11yo. But maybe it's not so different from their school Chromebook for what they need. Just removes some of the nice Apple family features and the apps they'd be inheriting, but that's what I get for not paying the tax with new hardware purchases.


11 is a great age to start learning Unix.

Edit: I know Mac OS X is a Unix and Linux is technically a clone, however, of the two, Linux & GNU is a much better environment to learn in.


I’ve got a “late 2008” MacBook Pro that connects to sites ok in Firefox. That seems to be the browser that does the best at long-term support for old Macs.


Both those machines will run the latest Ubuntu just fine, and the latest Chrome (or Firefox) on it.

Just copy the LiveCD image onto a USB stick, insert, boot holding down the Option key, and you can try it without actually installing it (i.e. leaving your MacOS untouched).


Good point. I remembered not getting Firefox to work but that was an even older Mac I was dusting off to run a birdcam installation.


My old macbook Air from 2010 is already running 6 years home assistant on Ubuntu. It's in my fuse/meter room running 24 hours.


It is 15 years old - I think it is past eWaste into antique.


You're talking to someone who's fixed their microwave several times to keep it going 20 years.


Nah, antiques are stuff like the apple 2 or the amiga, it was a different world back then

15 years old is just old and has too little ram


Sure. But my needs haven't exceeded that RAM. I just want to keep doing the things I was doing for years on it happily, but security updates, broken services and website bloat have intervened.


Just switch to linux and it should just work. There are distros that use very little ram and it stays updated. Noscript can help you block javascript on websites

A 15 year old device can be still as capable as a raspberry pi and those work fine now for modern computing


"the things I was doing for years" unfortunately involves several native apps. There's a reason I got a Mac, after all.


Depends if you use xcode or not...I still have my macbook 12inch, for work use, it is amazing, but I can't run the latest xcode, making it defunct for some of my uses. It would be fine running xcode weak as it is; i am sure. Liquid glass might have killed it tho.


I use one from around that time to teach my kid basic stuff, you can run linux on it as well.


Patches for old OS versions are unfortunately not 100% covering all security issues. Apple is often arguing that vulns can only be fixed in actively supported versions.


Also, would love to hear any tips you have for eeking out use...Sounds like you may have some...


You're not opening enough Chrome tabs. Or Electron apps.


You're clearly running low-intensity tasks (pro photo editing, music production, software dev, generally all at the same time) instead of highly-demanding ones (1 jira tab)


lol


So many articles I’ve read about the Mac Studio is how it very easily could be a 10year computer effortlessly.

The additional cooling in them seems quite helpful to their performance compared to the same chip in a laptop.


yup I'm an M1 max laptop, i actually went upto an m4 pro and went back the m1 max, it could handle more trading screens!


Obsolescence comes when Apple conveniently "optimizes" a new architecture in the OS for a new chip... that conveniently, ironically, somehow severely de-optimizes things for the old chips... and suddenly that shiny new OS feels slow and sluggish and clunky and "damn I need to upgrade my computer!." They'll whitewash it not as planned obsolescence but optimization for new products. Doesn't have to be that way, shouldn't be that way, but its incredibly profitable.


Maybe by that time ARM linux on this platform will be excellent and we can migrate to it for old gear. I still have a 2011 MBP running Linux on my electronics workbench and it is just fine.



Two drones doesn't really mean anything if they were following a similar flight plan to make a delivery at the same location right?


It means it wasn't a fluke or a bug specific to one drone, but something wrong in the overall software approach.


The repetition strongly indicates it’s a bug. No reason to think it points to a fundamental flaw in the approach.


i mean they both flew into invisible drone traps.

I don't know that amazon engineers should be expected to see e.g. a moving small steel cable under tension.

That and customers are required to select safe delivery drop zones.

I would like to see better "oh shit we're crashing let's try not to kill anyone" protection, e.g. research on improving controlled landings on damaged drones. Maybe refusal to deliver if there are any detected humans in the drop zone (which may well already exist).


It means Amazon’s approach to its “see and avoid” responsibility is fundamentally flawed in some way vs this being a one-off fluke with a broken sensor or other anomaly.


ok but also two drones crashing isn't "more" of a problem than one drone crashing really.

Sounds like the anamoly here was a very unsafe landing zone (which is outside the customer agreement as it happens).

small steel cables take out human pilots too..

Would be really curious how they might guard against adversarial drone deliveries. Kinda weird to have end users basically piloting your $100K (I'm guessing) vehicles.


At the same time? If there's a crash there should be an automatic system which geofences off that area making it impossible for other drones to go near there, while the situation is assessed.


If a drone crashes, obviously no other drones should fly there until a human determines what went wrong and presses the 'resume' button. The fact that that system did not exist is a systemic problem.


That sounds like an engineer-week of work not really a ground-up systemic problem. But fair criticism.


The systemic problem is that they didn't spend the engineer-week on it. It's only an engineer week. That pays for itself after avoiding a single drone crash to say nothing of avoiding a second lawsuit.


For commercial deliveries I would expect them to designate a landing zone guaranteed to be free of obstacles vertically. I'm guessing that installing radar detailed enough to see swinging cables is nearly impossible.


mmWave radar is commonly used for detecting (horizontal) cables of similar thickness in a very common use of enterprise drones: power line inspection.


guessing massive capital outlays and maybe irreversible site selection/preparation concerns.


I clicked around and the README links to this python lib: https://github.com/tcsenpai/pybooklid

Probably a nicer interface for anyone who wants to play with this :)


That’s a downstream project, the author’s original project is here [0], with much more information on the actual sensor.

0: https://github.com/samhenrigold/LidAngleSensor


isn't this only true if they are always pressurized?


They are always pressurised during normal use. When they are depressurised because of a water main break or for maintenance (and they try to do this as little as possible), orders are given to flush the lines before drinking any of the water.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: