Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yes. Same with browser plugins. I've heard multiple free-plugin authors say they're receiving regular offers to purchase their projects. I'm sure some must take up the offer.


For an example of a scary list of such offers, see https://github.com/extesy/hoverzoom/discussions/670


This is why I fork the extensions I use, with the exception of uBlock. Basically just copy the extension folder, if I can't find it on GitHub. That way I can audit the code and not have to worry about an auto-update sneaking in something nefarious. I've had two extensions in the past suddenly start asking for permissions they definitely did not need, and I suspect this is why.

Btw, here's a site where you can inspect an extension's source code before you install it: https://robwu.nl/crxviewer/


Yeah, and thx for the link to the neat crx explorer.

Close to what you do, I started writing my own addon to replace a couple addons whose featureset I use only partially.

For example, when I use Chromium I want 1. to customize the New Tab page, and 2. to add a keyboard shortcut to pin/unpinTab. These two features are absolutely part of extensions, but in addition to the security risk I find them heavy (I don’t need the kitchen sink, just need 2 micro-features!). And so, I have my little personal addon with zero resource usage with just these two features. It’s tiny (20 lines of code!), git-versioned, and never changes / gets pwned. When I need an extra micro-feature, it’s easy enough to add it by searching addons docs, of asking an LLM.


You shouldn’t need an extension just to add a keyboard shortcut for a menu item. Doesn’t your OS let you map that? On macOS you can in Keyboard Settings


Indeed, one point for MacOS! I use GNOME.


do you know of any other ones like this that post their offers?


No I don’t. But Wladimir Palant is where I get most of my information on the topic (and is probably where I got this link). His blog might have a post (or a comment) that links to similar lists: https://palant.info/categories/security/


This is cool but useless because they redacted all the company names. The opposite of a name and shame, because no name and no shame.


It's not useless. It shows the scale at which extension authors get offers for buyouts. The intended buyer doesn't exactly matter.


Precisely. Thank you.


I have long since stopped using any extension that doesn’t belong to an actual company (password managers for example). Even if they aren’t malware when you installed them, they will be after they get sold.


A bit off topic, but how is the bitwarden browser extension protected against supply-chain attacks (npm dependencies)?


Actual companies also get sold and churned into shit. See LastPass for example.


I got an outreach for an extension I made as a joke. It had like maybe 5000 downloads ever.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: