Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Stallman was talking about ChatGPT which isn't just an LLM.




He said:

> I call it a "bullshit generator" because it generates output "with indifference to the truth".

And if we follow the link we find he's referring to LLMs:

> “Bullshit generators” is a suitable term for large language models (“LLMs”) such as ChatGPT, that generate smooth-sounding verbiage that appears to assert things about the world, without understanding that verbiage semantically. This conclusion has received support from the paper titled ChatGPT is bullshit by Hicks et al. (2024).

No one thinks the database, orchestration, tool, etc. portions of ChatGPT are intelligent and frankly, I don't think anyone is confused by using LLM as shorthand not just for the trained model, but also all the support tools around it.


I wasn't thinking about their data store or other infrastructure. I was thinking about the layers added for reasoning and other functions that modify or guide the output of the LLM.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: